India celebrated the International Day of Yoga

0
On the picture H.E. Mr J.S. Mukul, Ambassador of India to the Netherlands. The Embassy of India and the Gandhi Centre, Cultural Wing of the Embassy, organised a massive event commemorating the International Day of Yoga 2016 (IDY 2016). H.E. Mr J.S. Mukul, Ambassador of India to the Netherlands, and his spouse Mita Mukul led more than six hundred people on a Saturday morning to practice a healthy yoga session at The Hague City Hall Atrium. Yoga has become immensely popular and is now practised by more 200 million people worldwide, including more than 100 million in India and 37.7 million in the U.S.   On arrival, guests were greeted with the almost futuristic sight of hundreds of yoga mats, all in the same colors and symmetrically positioned, filling up the huge atrium of the City Hall. Each guest was given a healthy goody bag from the counter by the Embassy staff with two fruits, a bottle of water, a brochure on the Gandhi Centre and a t-shirt promoting International Yoga Day 2016. For additional pictures, please open the following link: https://www.flickr.com/photos/121611753@N07/albums/72157669023268663 P_20160618_101428 - Copy Dutch civil servants, business people, representatives from the Indian diaspora, yoga lovers and novices alike all got at the same rhythm into the yoga mat to breath, and stretch under the direction of Mr. Amit Khanna, the Yoga Teacher at the Gandhi Centre. Yoga, a 5,000-year-old physical, mental and spiritual practice having its origin in India, aims to transform body and mind. The word ‘yoga’ which derives from Sanskrit means to join or to unite, symbolizing the union of body and consciousness.
P_20160618_101847 - Copy
H.E. Ambassador Mukul and Deputy Mayor Rabin Baldewsingh.
The United Nations recognized the universal appeal of yoga through the Adoption of its Resolution 69/131 on the International Day of Yoga. The declaration came after the call for the adoption of the same by Indian Prime Minister during his address to UN General Assembly on September 27, 2014 in which he stated: “Yoga is an invaluable gift of India’s ancient tradition. It embodies unity of mind and body; thought and action; restraint and fulfillment; harmony between man and nature; a holistic approach to health and well-being. It is not about exercise but to discover the sense of oneness with yourself, the world and nature.” P_20160618_105822 Ambassador Mukul addressed the gathering on the significance of Yoga Day for India and the value of practising yoga for health and wellbeing. The President of India, Shri Pranab Mukherjee, spoke by video conference to every nation in the world celebrating Yoga Day on 18 June. Deputy Mayor Rabin Baldewsingh was also present and gave encouraging words to the hundreds of attendees before the session began.  
P_20160618_112043
Professor Amit Khanna, Yoga Teacher at the Gandhi Centre.
The Secretary General to the United Nations stated that through the Adoption of the UN Resolution on the International Day of Yoga, “the General Assembly has recognized the holistic benefits of this timeless practice and its inherent compatibility with the principles and values of the United Nations”.
P_20160618_112249
Miss India Holland distributing healthy goody bags.
He further stated: “Yoga offers a simple, accessible and inclusive means to promote physical and spiritual health and well-being. It promotes respect for one’s fellow human beings and for the planet we share. And yoga does not discriminate; to varying degrees, all people can practice, regardless of their relative strength, age or ability.” After two hours of training, professor Khanna thanked the audience and invited all to practise Yoga regularly.
P_20160618_113025
Yoga Day 2016 in The Hague.
 

Aladin wind probe ready for Aeolus

0
It has been years in the making, but one of the trickiest pieces of space technology ever developed is finally ready to join its satellite for launch by the end of next year. With this milestone, we are another step closer to a better understanding of Earth’s winds. Carrying pioneering lasers, Aeolus will be the first satellite to probe the wind globally. These vertical slices through the atmosphere, along with information on aerosols and clouds, will advance our knowledge of atmospheric dynamics and contribute to climate research. Since Aeolus will deliver measurements almost in real time, it is also set to provide much-needed information to improve weather forecasts. Its state-of-the-art Aladin instrument, which was designed by Airbus Defence and Space in France, incorporates two powerful lasers, a large telescope and very sensitive receivers. The laser generates ultraviolet light that is beamed towards Earth. This light bounces off air molecules and small particles such as dust, ice and droplets of water in the atmosphere. The fraction of light that is scattered back towards the satellite is collected by Aladin’s telescope and measured.
Aladin ready for Aeolus. Photography by Airbus Defence and Space.
Aladin ready for Aeolus. Photography by Airbus Defence and Space.
Prof. Erland KĂ€llĂ©n, Director of Research at the European Centre for Medium Range Weather Forecasts, said, “The Aeolus mission will provide wind observations that are unique with respect to the current global observing system capabilities.”  Aladin ready for Aeolus “The observations fill a gap in the global observing system and despite the many years of delay there is still a need for the mission and we expect it to have a big impact on weather forecasting.  In the Tropics, wind information dominates atmospheric analyses and this influences the quality of weather forecasts for Europe for the week ahead. “ “Wind information from Aeolus is also expected to be important over oceans in both hemispheres for determining the position and evolution of jet streams and atmospheric fronts.” Developing advanced new space technologies is never easy and the Aeolus mission has certainly faced its share of challenges. For instance, the optics have to survive exposure to high-intensity laser pulses for at least three years in the unforgiving environment of space. Developing optics that could withstand these extremes took much longer than anticipated.
Aladin revealed.
Aladin revealed.
Aladin revealed Nevertheless, recent tests have shown that such technical problems have been resolved. Frederic Fabre, Project Manager for Aladin at Airbus Defence and Space, said, “This is very good news for the meteorologists and scientists who have been waiting some time for Aladin data to improve weather forecasting.” “The completion of the instrument is a result of the day-to day-involvement of the whole Aladin team including ESA, Airbus Defence & Space and several subcontractors throughout Europe.” Denny Wernham, ESA’s Aladin Instrument Manager, remarked, “The very successful results on Aladin are testimony to the dedication, determination and expertise of the team in Toulouse, who have overcome many technical hurdles to deliver the instrument to their UK colleagues. It is a really tremendous achievement and we would like to congratulate them for all their efforts.” ———— Pictures by ESA/ATG medialab.    

The Netherlands takes a critical stance in Syria Support Group

0
Today, at a session of the International Syria Support Group (ISSG) in Geneva, the Netherlands and several like-minded partners pressed for a breakthrough in the political process and the efforts to deliver direct aid to civilians in the city of Aleppo. More specifically, the Netherlands argued in favour of – at the very least – a temporary ceasefire, direct humanitarian aid and for the conditions to be met that will allow food drops over the besieged city. The Netherlands also took the position that as a neutral party, the UN should be given a leading role in providing humanitarian aid. Negotiations seem to be deadlocked, and much of Syria remains in the grip of violence. There is great frustration in the international community due to the parties’ failure to agree on a ceasefire in the country by 1 August. Thus far, the ISSG has not been able to force a breakthrough in the talks between the belligerents, foreign minister Bert Koenders observed. ‘This is irresponsible,’ said the minister. ‘It’s time for the ISSG and its co-chairs, the US and Russia, to shoulder their responsibility in preventing a humanitarian disaster in Aleppo.’ The Netherlands also urged the EU, which issued a statement yesterday at the initiative of the Netherlands, to adopt a more critical stance. The UN itself is in talks with representatives of the Assad regime. This task falls to Special Envoy for Syria Staffan De Mistura, who has been engaged on this front for some time. Up to this point, however, there has been insufficient progress. MINBUZA.MINISTRY.FOREIGN.AFFAIRS.NLFood drops The Netherlands is also working with the ISSG and humanitarian partners to reach Syrians in besieged areas. The Netherlands supports the UN World Food Programme (WFP) with a contribution of €3.3 million for food drops. Thanks in part to this support, the organisation has already been able to carry out 82 such drops in Deir ez-Zor, which is under siege by ISIS. ‘Dutch support for the WFP food drop programme is vital,’ Mr Koenders remarked. ‘Syrians need access to food – that’s obviously essential. The way the aid is delivered must be effective and safe. With that in mind the Netherlands and its partners have urged Russia to push for complete and unconditional humanitarian access to Aleppo and other parts of Syria.’ Minister for Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation Lilianne Ploumen added, ‘As difficult as it has been for them, the people of Deir ez-Zor have been able to survive thanks to these food drops. But this isn’t the only place where this type of emergency aid is needed.’ As Mr Koenders stressed, all parties concerned need to make humanitarian aid possible. ‘We have to focus on getting aid to Aleppo,’ he said. ‘Not on the forced relocation of people, which seems to be Russia’s aim. That’s a totally backwards approach.’ The minister’s remarks refer to the present ‘humanitarian corridors’, which are supposed to allow civilians to leave the city. The UN is not involved in these corridors. Considerable doubt exists about the safety of the corridors, and few people are using them. The Netherlands would also like to see an investigation of the suspected poison gas attack in the neighbouring Syrian city of Al-Saraqeb earlier this week. ‘A poison gas attack would be a serious violation of international humanitarian law,’ said Mr Koenders. In 2015 the UN Security Council adopted a resolution that created a Joint Investigative Mechanism (JIM) to look into the possible use of chemical weapons, including chlorine gas, in Syria. The Netherlands has proposed assigning investigation of this most recent attack to the JIM as well, in the hope that the perpetrators can be identified. The Netherlands has contributed €250,000 to the body’s valuable work. Picture by Henry Arvidsson.

Dutch state visits to Australia and New Zealand

0
Pictured the Dutch Royal couple. At the invitation of the Governor-General of the Commonwealth of Australia, Personal Representative of HM The Queen of Australia, HE The Hon General Sir Peter Cosgrove, His Majesty King Willem-Alexander and Her Majesty Queen Máxima of the Netherlands shall pay a state visit to Australia. The visit will take place from 31 October to 4 November 2016. Subsequently at the invitation of the Governor-General of the Realm of New Zealand, Personal Representative of HM The Queen of New Zealand, HE The Rt Hon Sir Jerry Mateparae, they will then pay a state visit to New Zealand from 7 to 9 November 2016. The visits will focus on the Netherlands’ historical and wide-ranging bilateral ties with Australia and New Zealand.
Dutch Foreign Minister HE Bert Kunders presenting the Kingom of The Netherlands canditature for a UN Security Council seat. The recption was held at the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs in The Hague, Netherlands
Dutch Foreign Minister HE Bert Kunders. Pictured by Henry Arvidsson.
The King and Queen will be accompanied by Foreign Minister Bert Koenders. A broad economic mission will take place at the same time, headed in Australia by Minister for Foreign Trade Lilianne Ploumen and in New Zealand by Minister of Economic Affairs Henk Kamp.       For further information: Embassy of Australia to the Netherlands: http://netherlands.embassy.gov.au Embassy of New Zealand to the Netherlands: https://www.mfat.govt.nz/en/countries-and-regions/europe/netherlands/new-zealand-embassy/   Picture by hortialliance.com    

Visions on Peace

0
This year, for the 9th time, the Dutch MA Thesis Prize “Visions on Peace” will be awarded to a Master student who wrote a thesis of exceptional quality in the field of peace and security issues. The thesis prize is an initiative of the Dutch Foundation for Peace Studies (Stichting Vredeswetenschappen, SVW), a foundation that wants to stimulate scientific knowledge and expertise in the field of peace and conflict. As of 2013 SVW cooperates with UPEACE Centre The Hague, the European centre of the UN mandated University for Peace, based in Costa Rica. Flyer Visions on Peace 2016 Deadline for application is 30 September 2016, 5 PM Dutch time. The application procedure can be found at www.visionsonpeace.nl. Eligible for the prize are Master students who:
  • Wrote a thesis related to peace and security issues.
  • Attended a Master’s study at a Dutch university or at another institution of higher education in The Netherlands.
  • Completed their thesis between 1 July 2015 and 1 September 2016. The thesis must be graded with a minimum of 8 and should be written in correct English or Dutch.
  • Send the application form and the other required documents to info@visionsonpeace.nl before 30 September 2016, 5 PM Dutch time.
  • Did not participate before in the “Visions on Peace” thesis competition.
The prize of € 1.500 is sponsored by the ASN Bank and will be awarded on 9 December 2016 at The Hague University of Applied Sciences, together with the award of the new HBO Peace Prize (see www.hbopeaceinpracticeresearchaward.nl). New Dissertation Prize: Respect for Refugee Rights, organized by the Dutch Council for Refugees and the International Institute of Social Studies in The Hague.

Belgium’s National Day

0
Pictured TRH Prince Emmanuel, The Duchess of Brabant, Prince Gabriel of Belgium and TM The Queen and King of the Belgians. Thursday, 21 July 2016, Brussels: His Majesty The King of the Belgians accompanied by HM Queen Mathilde of the Belgians and her children, reviewed as annually carried out by the monarch, a joint parade of the Armed Forces, police and emergency services. The parade took place according to tradition facing the Royal Palace of Brussels, including a flypast by the Air Force. HRH Prince Laurent of Belgium was the only other member of the Royal House present this year at the parade. For additional pictures, please open the following link: https://www.flickr.com/photos/121611753@N07/albums/72157671040083230
Belgian FM Didier Reynders, Senate Chair Christine Defraigne and Speaker at the Chamber of Deputies, Siegfried Bracke.
Belgian FM Didier Reynders, Senate Chair Christine Defraigne and Speaker at the Chamber of Deputies, Siegfried Bracke.
Belgium’s National Day is particularly linked to its Royal House as the latter fĂȘtes the swearing-in of the constitution by King Leopold I (Leopold of Saxe-Coburg and Gotha, Duke in Saxony) on 21 July 1831 at the Place Royale, Brussels. Thereby beginning the line of Saxe-Coburg monarchs reigning in Belgium ever since. 
French Ambassador Claude-France Arnould
French Ambassador Claude-France Arnould.
 After the military parade, heads of missions accredited to Belgium, the EU and NATO as well as prominent Belgians hailing from different walks of society were invited to a reception at Egmont Palace co-hosted by the country’s Vice-Prime Minister, Minister of Foreign Affairs, Foreign Trade and European Affairs, Didier Reynders, the President of the Senate, Christine Defraigne and the Speaker of the Chamber of Deputies, Siegfried Bracke. Belgian Prime Minister Charles Michel as well as Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Development Cooperation, Digital Agenda, Telecom and Postal Services, Alexander De Croo, also attended the elegant reception. 
Israel's Ambassador Simona Frankel (Belgium and Luxembourg).
Israel’s Ambassador Simona Frankel (Belgium and Luxembourg).
For further information: The Belgian Monarchy: https://www.monarchie.be/fr Didier Reynders: http://www.didierreynders.be ————— All pictures copywright to Jean-Pol Schrauwen, official photographer of Belgian Vice-Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs, Foreign Trade and European Affairs (https://www.flickr.com/photos/59502713@N02/)     

More migrants depart voluntarily from the Netherlands

0
 By Martin Wyss. The number of migrants opting for voluntary departure from the Netherlands to their countries of origin with the International Organization for Migration (IOM) is growing.  Under the IOM Assisted Voluntary Return and Reintegration (AVRR) programme from the Netherlands, 538 migrants were assisted in the month of June, compared to 429 migrants assisted in May. In the first half of the year, over 2,500 migrants departed under the same programme, or a 100 percent increase compared to the first six months of 2015, when 1,288 departed voluntarily from the Netherlands with IOM assistance. The main countries of origin for the period January-June 2016 were Afghanistan, Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Indonesia, Iran, Iraq, Kosovo, Mongolia, Serbia and Ukraine.  Voluntary return is a core activity of IOM in the Netherlands. Through the Assisted voluntary Return Programme (AVRR), IOM offers vital assistance to migrants who decide to leave voluntarily from the Netherlands to return to their country of origin. To be able to provide the needed assistance to migrants before, during and after their journey, IOM Netherlands works closely with partners in the Netherlands and with the worldwide network of IOM offices in over 100 countries.  Globally, in 2015 IOM assisted close to 70,000 migrants worldwide under the IOM Assisted Voluntary Return and Reintegration (AVRR) programmes. This was the largest number of voluntary returns registered in the past decades. The current migration trends seem to indicate that returns could increase in the years to come – not only in the number of migrants in need of assistance, but also in the complexity of the process. IOM emphasizes the importance of voluntary return policies that must guarantee the dignity and well-being of migrants, as well as offer practical reintegration support to returning migrants.  About IOM The International Organization for Migration (IOM) is the global lead agency on migration and works closely with governments, NGOs and intergovernmental partners. With 165 member states and more than 9,000 staff members IOM is dedicated to promoting human and orderly migration for the benefit of all.  IOM NL AVRR statistics and information http://www.iom-nederland.nl/nl/vrijwillig-vertrek/cijfers-vrijwillige-terugkeer. IOM Global AVRR statistics and information http://www.iom.int/sites/default/files/our_work/DMM/AVRR/AVRR_2015_Key_Highlights.pdf About the author: Martin Wyss is IOM International Organization  for Migration’s Chief of Mission in the Netherlands. For more information: contact Martin Wyss at mwyss@iom.int  

Top British talent Nicholas Collon new conductor of the Residentie Orkest

0
Top British talent Nicholas Collon becomes principal conductor of The Hague Philharmonic (Residentie) Orchestra   Nicholas Collon will make his official debut as principal conductor of The Hague Philharmonic (Residentie) orchestra in October. At just 33, this British innovator will be the youngest principal conductor in The Netherlands. Nicholas Collon has created an international frenzy with the Aurora Orchestra, which he founded in 2005 and of which he is the principal conductor. Creativity, the highest of quality, a wide-ranging artistic scope and an innovative approach to his audiences are among his key characteristics. The Hague Philharmonic Orchestra is therefore proud to have been able to secure the services of this young and energetic innovator, winner of the Critics’ Circle Award for Exceptional Talent in 2012, as its principal conductor. Collon succeeds in meshing modern repertoire with masterpieces from the classical and romantic traditions in a way that few others can. As well as conducting standard concerts,  he will also be getting involved in some special projects run by The Hague Philharmonic Orchestra, such as Symphonic Junction in Paard van Troje.
Nicholas Collon, by Maarten Fleskens.
Nicholas Collon, by Maarten Fleskens.
Sven Arne Tepl, artistic director of The Hague Philharmonic Orchestra, says “Nicholas is one of the highest profile young conductors of the day. Of course, this has a lot to do with his enormous versatility and depth as far as repertoire and style are concerned, but it’s mostly also about his immediate way of making music. The intense connection he forges with the musicians at his concerts can be sensed in the farthest corners of the auditorium, so our audiences will also feel intimately involved.” Collon makes his official debut as principal conductor in October – on Tuesday 25 October in the Concertgebouw and on Friday 28 October in the Zuiderstrandtheater. He has picked his own programmes for these concerts. In Amsterdam, he will conduct The Hague Philharmonic Orchestra in Tchaikovsky’s Overture Romeo and Juliet, Ravel’s G major Piano Concerto (with soloist Hannes Minnaar) and a selection from Prokofiev’s Suite Romeo and Juliet. In The Hague, he will conduct Walton’s Cello Concerto (with top cellist Alisa Weilerstein), Brahms’s Symphony no. 3 and Berlioz’s ScĂšne d’amour from RomĂ©o et Juliette. For information: Residentie Orkest, Nicholas Collon

From Breaking Barriers to Breaking Orbits: Hillary Clinton, the First Female nominee for US Presidency in a New Space Age

0
By Namira Salim, Founder and Chairperson, Space Trust. As Mr. Donald Trump stands as the Republican nominee, long time democrat and women’s rights champion, Mrs. Hillary Clinton will face a challenge unlike she, nor any politician, has faced before.‎ However, facing and overcoming adversity is inherent in Mrs. Clinton’s DNA.  She, like so many women before her and undoubtedly those to come, is hard-wired to buck what has been deemed ‘tradition’ and to break trends and barriers; be these related to ethnicity, creed or gender. In this new age of space exploration, which we call the advent of the ‘Commercialization of Space’ Mrs. Clinton’s efforts are timely; they ensure that the next generation of world ‎leaders and especially, women leaders, are given equal and ample opportunity to succeed. training_certificate-01 However, since I was born in Pakistan, I have no partisan bias in the U.S. voting process. Yet, despite my nation being a developing one, with its own burden of geopolitical crises in recent history, it remains the first Muslim nation in the world to have democratically elected the First Female Prime Minister, Ms. Benazir Bhutto in 1988. And so today we see a paradigm shift – a U.N. Secretary General campaign is currently spearheaded by talented women candidates such as Ms. ‎Natalia Gherman‎,  former ‎Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Integration of Moldova, and Ms. Irina Bokova, Director General UNESCO originally from Bulgaria; we have long looked to the stewardship of Ms. Angela Merkel, German Chancellor and Ms. Christine Lagarde, Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund. Inspired by such women leaders, I have ventured to break down ‘man-made barriers’, having become the First Pakistani to have undertaken pioneering Peace expeditions to the North Pole in 2007 and South Pole in 2008, ‎as well as the first Asian to Skydive (tandem) over Mount Everest in 2008 and next, to become the first Pakistani to go to Space as Founder Astronaut of Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin Galactic, the first private Space-line in the world. Namira Salim Portrait 2016 My dream of ‘breaking orbits’ is one shared by many. And it is worth remembering that politics was not always Mrs. Clinton’s choice of career. As a young girl, she too dreamt of becoming an astronaut and in fact, even wrote to NASA regarding her ambition.  In her 2003 Memoir ‘Living History’, Mrs. Clinton quoted NASA’s response as the following – ‘We are not accepting girls as astronauts.’  While today, ‘Gender Equality and Women Empowerment’ is regarded as a fundamental human right under the United Nation’s Millennium Development Goals and remains a necessity for a peaceful and prosperous world, this was not always the status quo. To date, 59 women have flown in space, out of a total of 536 space travelers. Russia’s Valentina Tereshkova was the first woman in Space in 1963, less than two years after‎ fellow Cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin became the first human in space.  While Mrs. Clinton’s dreams of space flight were stifled then by the societal restrictions of the period, there were many who championed women’s rights before her to help secure all of our future ambitions, in arenas Mrs. Clinton would come to be known for championing.‎ Victoria Woodhull, for example, was also an activist, politician and author, much like Mrs. Clinton and was arguably, the first woman to run for the Presidency of the United States. A free thinker, Ms. Victoria Woodhull created ‘Claflin’s Weekly,’ a radical publication, in 1870 alongside her sister. The journal gave them a soapbox to stand on, a platform to express their ideas on social reform, including women’s suffrage. The journal was also and controversially, the first to publish an English translation of Karl Marx’s ‘Communist Manifesto.’‎ No doubt a strong supporter of women’s rights, Ms. Woodhull, who had already broken the ‘rules’ by becoming the first woman stockbroker, later established the Equal Rights Party, and shortly thereafter, became the first female candidate in history to seek the United States Presidency on the political group’s ticket. No matter the result, Ms. Woodhull stands as a pioneer; a ‘Founder’ of an ideology that has driven American society to astronomical heights.  She would eventually live long enough to see women be given the right to vote in 1920. And today, her efforts have had a trickle down effect the world over, where we see a diverse array of women vying for prestigious roles in unprecedented competitions.‎ ‎ As a Founder Astronaut of Virgin Galactic, which will also make me the first (future) South Asian Space Tourist, I have pursued dreams that would have been unthinkable for women less than a generation ago; I trust my story has inspired women internationally and I hope to continue to encourage the Space generation of women leaders to reach for the stars.
Official Training Photo
Namira Salim, First (future) South Asian Space Tourist experiences G forces in the STS – 400 simulator at the NASTAR Center in the US, during her official spaceflight training with Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin Galactic.
I am particularly sensitive to those regions where women and girls continue to be victims of discrimination and violence; where hope is an invaluable commodity and too often, in short supply. Perhaps, female leadership with an ample dose of sensitivity is the answer?  Can the first female President of the United States and the first female Secretary General of the United Nations work hand in hand to accomplish such humanity, for example?
After Mrs. Clinton missed out on the Democratic Party’s nomination in 2008, she memorably said, “…Although we weren’t able to shatter that highest, hardest glass ceiling this time, thanks to you, it’s got about 18 million cracks in it.”  While we can celebrate each crack, we can never rest until the ceiling is well and truly smashed and I look forward to my contributing to that process from Space.‎ As, to put it in Victoria Woodhull’s words, “While others prayed for the good time coming, I worked for it.”  It is now up to the next generation of women leaders to follow suit. Ms. Namira Salim is a Future Astronaut, globally recognised polar explorer, Founder and Chairperson of Space Trust, an enterprise devoted to Making Space the New Frontier for Peace.  She is based in the Principality of Monaco.  The views expressed here are her own.

Against the abusive invocation of self-defence against terrorism

0
By Nicolas Boeglin. A collective open letter signed by a great number of professors of international law and researchers entitled « A plea against the abusive invocation of self-defence as a response to terrorism » is circulating on the web for a few weeks. Among the signatories, of which there are more than 230 professors and 50 assistants/researchers (see the list available here at July 29, regularly updated by the Centre de Droit International de lÂŽUniversitĂ© Libre de Bruxelles, ULB) , we find distinguished members of international law community as well a younger researchers and assistants. The objective of this collective initiative is to challenge the invocation of the legal argument of self-defence by several States in the context of the so called “war” against ISIL or ISIS. As well known, the United Nations Charter is extremely clear on the unique exception to the prohibition of the use of force since 1945: self-defence (and military operations authorized by Security Council under Chapter VII of the Charter). However, since 9/11, interpretations made by United States and its allies have tried to legally support unilateral military operations in the territory of a State without previous consent of its authorities. In a recent note published on the website of the prestigious European Journal of International Law (EJIL), we read that: “Particularly since 9/11, several States have supported a broad reading of the right to use force in self-defence, as allowing them to intervene militarily against terrorists whenever and wherever they may be. A consequence of that conception is that any State could be targeted irrespective of whether that State has ‘sent’ the irregular (in this case terrorist) group to carry out a military action or has been ‘substantially involved’ in such an action” (Note 1). The use of force in self-defence must be exercised in conformity with the conditions laid down in international law, and particularly the UN Charter. On this very particular last point, it must be recalled that France presented to the Security Council a quite surprising draft resolution after Paris attacks of November 13, 2015 (see full text of the « blue version » circulated among delegations) avoiding any reference to the Charter in its operative paragraphs: it is possibly a great “premiĂšre” of French diplomacy at the United Nations (Note 2). The text of this global call (available here ) in French, English, Portuguese, Spanish and Arabic) considers, among others arguments, that: « Thus, numerous military interventions have been conducted in the name of self-defence, including against Al Qaeda, ISIS or affiliated groups. While some have downplayed these precedents on account of their exceptional nature, there is a serious risk of self-defence becoming an alibi, used systematically to justify the unilateral launching of military operations around the world».   «Without opposing the use of force against terrorist groups as a matter of principle — particularly in the current context of the fight against ISIS — we, international law professors and scholars, consider this invocation of self-defence to be problematic. In fact, international law provides for a range of measures to fight terrorism. Priority should be given to these measures before invoking self-defence ». For the signatories of this collective letter, «  . we consider that terrorism raises above all the challenge of prosecution and trial of individuals who commit acts of terrorism. A variety of legal tools are available in this respect. They relate first and foremost to police and judicial cooperation (chiefly through agencies such as INTERPOL or EUROPOL), aiming both at punishing those responsible for the crimes committed and preventing future occurrence of such crimes. Although there is certainly room for improvement, this cooperation has often proved effective in dismantling networks, thwarting attacks, and arresting the perpetrators of such attacks. By embracing from the outset the « war against terrorism » and « self-defence » paradigms and declaring a state of emergency, there is a serious risk of trivializing, neglecting, or ignoring ordinary peacetime legal processes”. It must be noted that this document is open for signature by international law scholars and researchers around the world until next September 1st. The text recalls a certain number of very clear rules that diplomats and judges at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague, and diplomats in New York know better than anyone, despite the ambiguous interpretations made by some of their colleagues at the Security Council, in particular since the beginning of airstrikes in Syria, without the consent of its authorities (Note 3). This document also refers that: «  , the maintenance of international peace and security rests first and foremost with the Security Council. The Council has qualified international terrorism as a threat to the peace on numerous occasions. Therefore, aside from cases of emergency leaving no time to seize the UN, it must remain the Security Council’s primary responsibility to decide, coordinate and supervise acts of collective security». « Confining the task of the Council to adopting ambiguous resolutions of an essentially diplomatic nature, as was the case with the passing of resolution 2249 (2015) relating to the fight against ISIS, is an unfortunate practice. Instead, the role of the Council must be enhanced in keeping with the letter and spirit of the Charter, thereby ensuring a multilateral approach to security /
/ However, the mere fact that, despite its efforts, a State is unable to put an end to terrorist activities on its territory is insufficient to justify bombing that State’s territory without its consent». «Such an argument finds no support either in existing legal instruments or in the case law of the International Court of Justice. Accepting this argument entails a risk of grave abuse in that military action may henceforth be conducted against the will of a great number of States under the sole pretext that, in the intervening State’s view, they were not sufficiently effective in fighting terrorism». It must be noted that in February 2016, Canada new authorities decided to cease airstrikes in Syria and Iraq. We read on this official note produced by Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) that: “ In accordance with Government of Canada direction, the Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) ceased airstrike operations in Iraq and Syria on 15 February 2016. From their first sortie on 30 October 2014 to 15 February 2016, the CF-188 Hornets conducted 1378 sorties resulting in 251 airstrikes (246 in Iraq and 5 in Syria), expended 606 munitions and achieved the following effects: 267 ISIL fighting positions, 102 ISIL equipment and vehicles, and, 30 ISIL Improvised Explosive Device (IED) factories and ISIL storage facilities”. In 2015, a Canadian scholar concluded an extremely interesting article on airstrikes in Syria and Iraq in the following terms: “However, there is a further legal hurdle for Canada to overcome. Unless Canada can attribute ISISÂŽ attacks in Iraq to Syria, then the question becomes whether Canada may lawfully target ISIS, as a nonstate actor in Syria’s sovereign territory, using the ‘unwilling or unable’ doctrine to prevent ISIS’ extraterritoriality attacks against Iraq. This justification moves significantly away from the Nicaragua, Congo and Israeli Wall cases’ requirement for attribution. There appears to be a lack of consensus on whether opinion juris and state practice have accepted the “unwilling or unable” doctrine as customary international law. There is no escaping the conclusion that Canada’s air strikes on Syria are on shaky, or at least shifting, legal ground ” (Note 4).
Graphic on airstrikes in Syria launched by United States (blue color) and "Arab allies and Canada" (in red color) from December 2014 to August 2015, published in this report of Airwars.org entitled: "First year of Coalition airstrikes helped stall Islamic State – but at a cost ".
Graphic on airstrikes in Syria launched by United States (blue color) and “Arab allies and Canada” (in red color) from December 2014 to August 2015, published in this report of Airwars.org entitled: “First year of Coalition airstrikes helped stall Islamic State – but at a cost “.
  Concerning airstrikes in Syria and Iraq by coalition member States (see for example the detailed report for July 2106 prepared by the NGO Airwars.org), the systematic registry of every single airstrike give a more complete idea on how tasks are shared inside the coalition: illustrative charts realized by Airwars.org clarify the fact that bombs exploding in those two States are mainly dropped from United States aircrafts . In particular, a careful reading of Chart 9 of the before mentioned link (see the column corresponding to July 2016) shows that at July 25st, in Syria 4414 airstrikes from United States have took place in July 2016, while 249 were realized by other coalition members (officially 10 States are part to the coalition in Syria, to which Canada cannot be included anymore concerning airstrikes (nor in Syria, nor in Iraq), and that since February 2016). With regard to civilian harm in Syria caused by airstrikes, a recent report of June 2016 states that: ”This raises concerns that important, corroborating information was either never identified or discounted with little justification, a concern confirmed by a comparison to an investigation by Airwars into one of the strikes involved, which demonstrates that open source data was overlooked. As a result of these apparent shortcomings, it is highly likely that there is a significant amount of information regarding civilian harm and its strategic impact that the United States simply does not know”(p. 55). The signatories of this collective call, whose number increase from day to day, including scholars from different continents and age, conclude reaffirming that: « The international legal order may not be reduced to an interventionist logic similar to that prevailing before the adoption of the United Nations Charter. The purpose of the Charter was to substitute a multilateral system grounded in cooperation and the enhanced role of law and institutions for unilateral military action. It would be tragic if, acting on emotion in the face of terrorism (understandable as this emotion may be), that purpose were lost ». —— About the author: Nicolas Boeglin is professor of International Law, Law Faculty, Universidad de Costa Rica (UCR).   Note 1: See CORTEN O., « A Plea Against the Abusive Invocation of Self-Defence as a Response to Terrorism”, European Journal of International Law (EJIL Talk), July 14, 2016, available here . Note 2: See ou modest note published in France, BOEGLIN N., «Attentats Ă  Paris : remarques Ă  propos de la rĂ©solution 2249 », ActualitĂ©s du Droit, December 6, 2015, available here . See also, after parliamentary debate in United Kingdom authorizing airstrikes in Syria, BOEGLIN N. «Arguments based on UN resolution 2249 in Prime MinisterÂŽs report on airstrikes in Syria: some clarifications needed », Human Rights Investigation, December 4, 2015, available here . Note 3: On the notion of « unwilling or unable » State, justifying, for some diplomats, military operations on its territory without its previous consent, see: CORTEN O., “The ‘Unwilling or Unable’ Test: Has it Been, and Could it be, Accepted?”, Leiden Journal of International Law, 2016. Absrtract of this article available here . Note 4: See LESPERANCE R.J. , “Canada’s Military Operations against ISIS in Iraq and Syria and the Law of Armed Conflict”, Canadian International Lawyer, Vol. 10 (2015), pp. 51-63, p. 61. Full text of the article available here . Â